Television Interview with Natalie Barr – Sunrise – Friday 1 November 2024

E&OE TRANSCRIPT
TELEVISION INTERVIEW
SUNRISE, SEVEN SYDNEY
FRIDAY, 1 NOVEMBER 2024

SUBJECTS: MP’s travel 

NATALIE BARR: Well, after a week of criticising the Prime Minister for avoiding questions over Qantas flight upgrades, Peter Dutton has found himself up in the air for asking Gina Rinehart for a lift on her private jet.

On Tuesday the Opposition Leader was asked if he had personally requested the trip from the mining billionaire to which he replied, “No”. But on Thursday he conceded his office had in fact made such a request to Australia’s richest person.

For their take, let’s bring in Deputy Opposition Leader, Sussan Ley and Education Minister, Jason Clare. Good morning to both of you.

JASON CLARE, MINISTER FOR EDUCATION: Good morning.

SUSSAN LEY: Good morning.

BARR: Sussan, you guys have basically spent the week attacking Albo for all his flight upgrades. Was that a mistake given your own house may not be in order?

LEY: I think it’s pretty disappointing, Nat, that Labor is going after Peter Dutton because of a flight to the Bali Bombing Memorial after the government refused him a government flight. Now they should have supported him going to the Bali Bombing Memorial, absolutely they should have.

The issue here is that we’ve got a serious journalist, Joe Aston, who is saying that the Prime Minister solicited, sought upgrades to his personal travel while he was that one person in the Parliament who was in charge of regulating the laws around airlines. So ‑‑

BARR: Okay, Sussan, what about your Shadow Transport Minister ‑‑

LEY: Six days, six different answers ‑‑

BARR: ‑‑ who may have broken parliamentary rules because she can’t remember whether she asked for upgrades? 

LEY: And she has asked the airlines and been very transparent and upfront about seeking advice ‑‑

BARR: Isn’t that what the other side are doing?

LEY: ‑‑ for something she said she may not have had a complete recollection of. Not at all. Remember, Nat, that one person in the Parliament who has the responsibility, the executive responsibility for regulating the laws around airlines. We just haven’t got a straight answer from the Prime Minister.

BARR: Well, we haven’t got a straight answer from your Shadow Transport Minister though.

LEY: We’ve had six answers in six different days. She’s asked the questions; she’s waiting for the reply. She’s not in an equivalent position ‑‑

BARR: But that’s exactly what Albo’s been doing all week, isn’t it? 

LEY: ‑‑ as Anthony Albanese was. No, what he’s been doing is avoiding the question completely; six days, six different answers, and this is something we need to take further, because it’s not good enough. We’ve got another serious journalist, Sam Maiden, saying today that maybe his staff solicited those upgrades. We had his carefully curated set of one‑word answers. This is not good enough, and I would say to Jason and his colleagues, you don’t need to go into bat for Upgrade Albo and his dodgy deals; he wouldn’t do the same for you.

BARR: Okay. Jason. Let’s talk about why it took the Prime Minister all these days to answer that question.

CLARE: To check. To make sure that that the information that he was providing was accurate.

BARR: Wouldn’t he know if he’d asked for upgrades?

CLARE: If you’ve been in Parliament for a long time, you’d want to make sure that you go through all those records that are more than a decade long, and he’s done that, and that’s the difference between the Prime Minister and Peter Dutton.

Peter Dutton was asked the same question, and he lied. The key here is declare it if it’s happened, and be honest about it, and where Peter Dutton has come unstuck ‑ this is not about the Bali Bombing, this is about basic decency and honesty ‑ Peter Dutton was asked, did he ask billionaire Gina Rinehart to use her private plane, and he said, “No”. Now it turns out that that’s a lie.

So, the bloke who’s been attacking the Prime Minister uphill and down dale all week about this is guilty of the thing that he wrongly accused the Prime Minister of.

So when Peter Dutton eventually fronts the camera today, he needs to answer the question, “Why did he lie”?

BARR: We’ve now also got Qantas insiders who say it’s not just your ministers, like people like you who pick up the phone, it’s your office staff. Does that happen?

CLARE: Well, maybe it does, I don’t know.

BARR: Is that what you do?

CLARE: I’d have to check my records for upgrades in the last 10 years. But the bottom line is where it happens, declare it, fill out a form, make sure that the whole world can see about it. Don’t lie about it. That’s what’s happened here.

BARR: Well, Albo hasn’t said whether his staff have picked up the phone and asked for upgrades.

CLARE: In answer to all the questions he’s been asked, he’s made it clear that he hasn’t asked for an upgrade, right.

BARR: But he hasn’t. What about his staff?

CLARE: You have to ask Albo, right.

BARR: What about you? Have you asked for upgrades?

CLARE: I’d have to check. Again, my first answer I gave you was you’ve got to make sure that you’re honest here. I’m not going to give you an answer that’s wrong, so I’d have to check.

BARR: So, you’re going it check. What about your staff? You’ll check if they’ve asked as well? 

CLARE: Absolutely, absolutely.

BARR: Okay. A lot of checking going on. I think we’ll leave it there. Lots of checking going on from both sides. Thank you very much.

ENDS